FW: [Tig] D-Cinema Suite contd.
Sat Mar 8 21:23:38 GMT 2003
Stan Chayka wrote:
> The point to consider is that when the white bar is exposed, the light level
> behind the pluge area is actually higher making the point of extinction that
> much harder to set.
> Kind of like having a bias light inside the crt.
> This results in a monitor calibration that compensates for this effect under
> the conditions of color bars but not necessarily typical picture content.
> This effect may not be present in a projection system and would cause the
> colorist to determine the blacks with a different viewpoint.
> I would like to think that if the pluge is used to set the extinction point,
> it be done without the contamination of the color bars, and, then see if the
> blacks match better with projection systems.
Interestingly, I have a couple of PAL generators which have a pluge set amidst a largely black field. Perhaps the Europeans noticed some of these problems and configured their test signals accordingly - at least to eliminate the contamination of the bars,
What should we do? Put a pluge in a grey field? or perhaps in a screen full of some kind of random pattern? or take an average of settings made under two or three conditions? Another suggestion might be a very tall pluge set over a vertical wash from
top to bottom of the screen. It wouldn't eliminate the contamination problems, but would allow the user to judge an average of varying picture level conditions...
More information about the Tig